And that's what we got.....well, sort of.
As a Freddy fan , I was excited to be able to see my favorite character ,the makeup and glove in action each week.Plus the exploration of Nightmare themes and dreams.Any story could be possible in the world of dreams.One week we could have a typical suburban nightmare,the next,the characters story could take place entirely in space as a part of the main victims dream.Like ones own dreams, the story possibilities,barring budget restraints, could be endless.The Nightmare films themselves,unlike Friday the 13th films, often had more going on in the story than just the slaughtering of teenagers.So there was hope that since dreams are often rife with symbolism draped communications of desires that the show could really play up on that aspect with each episode.Each story could be an exploration of the subconscious.Plus, being a weekly show,and even though episodes were made weeks in advance, there was potential for Freddy and the show to be used to turn the current teenager fad on its head.
However, The thrust of what became Freddy's Nightmares was a standard horror anthology series that took place in the fictional town of Springwood,OH.And it never strayed to far from that basic concept.
Each week a new selection of characters would be introduced and subsequently suffer bad dreams that lead to a terrible fate shortly thereafter,often rarely surviving more than one commercial break.
Each episode would feature Freddy Krueger, not primarily as a participant ,but rather as a Rod Serling-esque host who appeared in sequences what are referred to in television production as bumpers. Intended pauses in the program before commercial breaks.
Often Freddy would pop up within the first five minutes after the opening of the show to make a comment on the impending fate of this weeks victim. "Johnny has big dreams of making it in Hollywood, but he is about to find out that getting out of Springwood alive ..*puts on sunglasses*...can be a real nightmare" *YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHH *
Freddy would crack a macabre joke about the previous scenes events or if it was after the characters denouement, he would eerily eulogize their fate.
The show ran for a full hour.And at the halfway mark we would be introduced to another persons story.This character was often somehow connected directly to the victim of the first half or was a background player to that story.
This consistent two story motif was unique.However the split of stories over the length of one episode brought home the fact that the show really didn't need to be an hour long.As the too often thinly written characters were then stretched even thinner over the second half of the show.Spending a half hour with them was enough.If they had focused more on telling a complete story in a single half hour they might not have needed to stretch each episodes budget over the whole hour.
On rare occasions , Fred Krueger himself would be the main focus of the story.But these stories were few and far between much to Freddy fans chagrin. In the end , I think we had 8 Freddy focused stories in total by the end of the shows run..
One of these Freddy focused occasions was in the very first episode,and not only was Freddy a featured participant but this show was where they attempted to depict what happened to Freddy the night he was burned alive.
The night he became...."No More Mr Nice Guy" (cue up the Alice Cooper song)
Though despite a intriguing fan friendly premise for a pilot episode, starting with a Freddy-centric story did set the wrong expectations for what would come next week and beyond.Honestly, what was the point of it being Freddy?Since Krueger would subsequently be shown to not have a direct involvement in every episode.On rare occasions it was merely hinted that Freddy was the reason the main character's luck ran bad and not that we were shown him directly influencing the events through his actions. Say for example, a character is in a desperate hurry to get somewhere fast.Before this person gets in his or her car we are shown Freddy appearing under the said car and slicing the break line or puncturing the tires.
It's not surprising that they opted to tell stories that DIDN'T revolve directly around Freddy Krueger.The need to have Robert Englund in makeup alone every week for months at a time would have been too much of a chore.Both costly and physically.As it was, they could film many if not most of the series Krueger inserts over a couple of days since most of them were filmed on the same "Interior Nightmare" set.Reducing the amount of consecutive times Robert had to go under the glue and be buried in full makeup.
If it had been designed as a show where he would have to be heavily involved in the storyline itself every week,Englund would have found himself under the makeup for long stretches.12 hour plus days that started with early calls just to spend close to 3hrs to get in the makeup in the first place.And then have to wear it for at least 8 more hours in a row under hot lights,dry ice fog filled sets, and exertion (all while wearing the trademark sweater). And then go home and do it all over again the next day.And the day after that?And then start all over again on a new episode the next week.I can't imagine they could have offered him enough money to agree to that.
In an anthology setting it would be difficult to come up with weekly tales where each week new main characters die by Freddy's glove and still keep it interesting.If the character is dull and one dimensional, who cares what happens to them?If we do care about the characters introduced, we don't want to turn in each week just to watch them die. The villain may get all the press , but the Monster is nothing without his heroine.And Horror fans love to watch their Ladies fight back against the abuse put upon them.WE love to watch them survive the night.
Now,they could have chosen to tell a seasons long Nightmare on Elm Street related story where Freddy sliced his way through the cast every other episode,but a season long horror story was not really something that had been tried before.Years later,series like the new Doctor Who and Buffy the Vampire Slayer would effectively balance not only the monster of the week story but also the overarching season length storyline.If they ever decided to do another Elm Street related show,this is the route they should take.A season long arc that builds on it's characters and their struggles with the Nightmare.
As it was, even with Freddy's indirect involvement the show struggled to tell stories that were compelling.The main characters of each story seemed to experience the same type of dreams over and over.Strangely, a large portion of the episodes told stories about unrelatable adults with their dreams and problems,rather than teenagers, which one would think was the target audience for this show.Teenage angst,typical growing up troubles and fears would be a deep well to pull from for stories. What if you were the kid picked on by the school bully,that experience is sure to invade your dreams.And in these Freddy's Nightmare's influenced night terrors its something much worse.You cant escape the real horror even when you go home to rest.And you can't tell the difference when you wake.How far would you go to end the "Nightmare"? Bring your father's gun to school?
I've always had a trouble getting into anthology shows.While I appreciate the opportunity for the show to explore multiple aspects of it's theme, I find it hard to get invested in the characters or have the story grab me as I know this is it, once this show is over they or this stories world will be gone,never to be visited again.
That being said, shows like The Twilight Zone,Alfred Hitchcock Presents or Tales from the Crypt to name a few, I love and will often watch in repeat.
Maybe it was because shows like Twilight Zone managed to touch on different genres each week.If you didn't care for the concept of the story one week, don't worry, next week would present you something completely new.The half hour programing of most of these shows kept the storytelling compact and concise,like a well written radio play, as it couldn't afford time for filler.The shows were effective in their weekly world building.Quite often leaving you wanting more from that story,in a good way.Twilight Zone also managed in its less than half hour running time to create characters each week that held your interest.Culminating in a twist or surprise ending to the characters fate,often laced with a morality tale.
Tales from the Crypt gave us over the top comic book style horror and gore with most of the main characters suffering a deserved fate due to their questionable morals.The monster of the week show can be very appealing.Even if only for the special effects aspect alone.But this show had it's own style and humor to frame the picture.And a host of famous directors to boot.
Sadly, Freddy's Nightmares had little to none of that. No intriguing monster of the week,despite having a built in one in Freddy himself.Not enough interesting world building( i.e. - a LOT of interior loft type stories). No morality tales with surprising twists of fate.Just bland characters experiencing bland bad dreams with our friendly neighborhood French fried host quipping bad puns and proclamations from the sidelines.You knew their number was up before the first commercial break.Heck, I don't think any of our main characters got out of their stories alive.
I don't like knocking people's efforts.A lot of work goes into making a fantasy heavy television show or movie despite the outcome.And I'm sure whether it was the set dresser or a director,they all showed up to work intending to do a good job and make a entertaining program with the limited means they were provided.But the show just felt like it was rushed in it's production and too weakened by it's weekly budget.Too often the actors struggled to bring their characters up to one dimension let alone two. The show never established a visual style that would carry through from episode to episode. Dreams were too often represented by the same smoke machines and the same purple lighting and shadows.
That's not to say it was all bad.I watched every episode live.And at least once or twice later on my home made VHS tapes.If it were ever to be released on DVD , I'd buy it day one.